Challenge #4 ~ “2 books by different authors whose names rhyme: Book 1.”
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
My opinion in three sentences:
This was a fun start to what I’m hoping continues as a fun, accessible, and modern take on the child spy trope. The plot focuses on some contemporary issues (e.g. the climate crisis) but does so in a manner that is educational without being dull, in a balance that is perfect the middle grade audience. Furthermore, Ponti demonstrates great research and skill with the diverse range of characters, making it relatable to those from a whole host of backgrounds.
(Without spoiling anything) the best bit:
City Spies is a fantastic example of high-quality middle grade literature. It is well-written throughout with great representation among the characters. Ponti also juggles several levels to the storyline with the fun and light-hearted balanced well alongside the more serious, showcasing complexity and depth that is often lacking in MG reads. These are the heights middle grade novels could reach if only they were allowed to fly.
A warning for the book:
Don’t judge a book by its title. I was so unenthused by the title that I overlooked this book several times when choosing what to read next – it’s just so uninspiring and at complete contrast with the clever twists in the actual plot. There’s a literal explanation towards the end of the book, and whilst I agree it works for the team and/or series name, I think it lets the book down as a title. It’s a fun, strong start to a series – let’s intrigue an audience, not have them brush it off!
Recommended for fans of:
- Hostage by Chris Bradford
- The Haven by Simon Lelic
- Don’t Trust a Girl by Her Cover by Ally Carter
Dreaming With Your Eyes Wide Open 